SARL vs SAS, which legal form to choose?

Accounting expertise | Asset Management

by Rémy Brachet, Altermès partner in charge of public accounting

Choosing the right legal structure (SAS or SARL) is an important step in setting up a business, and has a direct influence on the future of the structure, particularly in terms of :

  • Corporate taxation
  • The social security system for managers
  • The company’s future development (arrival of partners or investors, etc.)
  • How the company operates (business sector, partners, etc.)

SARL (limited liability company)

Benefits

  • Possibility of creating a company with a single shareholder (EURL);
  • Partners’ liability limited to contributions;
  • Possibility of being taxed at IR under certain conditions (EURL or SARL de famille);
  • The remuneration of the majority shareholder falls under the category of non-salaried workers (self-employed), which results in a lower rate of social security contributions than that of an employee (contribution rate of 40 – 45% vs. 75% – 80% for the director of an SAS);

Disadvantages

  • By-laws and rules of governance governed by the French Commercial Code;
  • The majority shareholder is classified as a self-employed worker, which means that his or her social security protection is inferior to that of an employee (old age/work accident);
  • Minimum flat-rate social security contributions for the manager (TNS) despite the absence of remuneration (particularly during the start-up phase);
  • The calculation of social security contributions is based on income n-2 or n-1, which means that there is a cash flow gap to be anticipated (particularly in the start-up phase);
  • Dividends are partially subject to social security contributions, which means that the tax cost of dividends is higher than under the SAS system;

SAS (simplified joint-stock company)

Benefits

  • Possibility of creating a company with a single shareholder (SASU);
  • Partners’ liability limited to contributions;
  • Great freedom in the drafting of bylaws (possibility of creating management bodies with specific rules according to management needs);
  • Managers (Chairman, CEO, etc.) are treated as employees, which means that they enjoy a high level of social protection (old age/work accident);
  • Possibility of paying dividends at the 30% tax rate;
  • No minimum social security contributions in the absence of remuneration (particularly during the start-up phase);
  • The tax system for the sale of SAS shares is more advantageous than that of the SARL;

Disadvantages

  • Social security contributions on salaries are almost 2 times higher than those applied to self-employed workers;
  • Possibility of being taxed on income tax for a limited period of 5 years;

Conclusion

In conclusion, the choice of legal structure depends essentially on the current and future personal and professional situation of the entrepreneur(s).

It’s an important choice that shouldn’t be overlooked.

👆 Altermès offers business start-up support to help you make the right choices!

❓ A question? A project? Don’t hesitate to contact us!

giphy

Related topics

5 Tips for managing your personal assets

Obtaining additional income for retirement, protecting your spouse and children, investing in real estate or the financial markets, facilitating transmission or inheritance... All this is possible thanks to effective personal wealth management. Whether it's €1,000 or...

read more