Intragroup receivables: recording an impairment is not enough to secure its tax deduction

Lawyers

The principle nevertheless remains favourable: a provision on a receivable held on a subsidiary is in principle deductible, and the tax authorities must give precise reasons for challenging it (CE, 12 March 2025, no. 474824, SC Saint-Louis). Two recent decisions, however, show where the weak points lie.

1. At year-end: proving the impairment

In the Solano Investissements case, a company had recorded a provision of €450,000 against the advances it had granted to its Moroccan subsidiary. The court refused the deduction: the factual and financial evidence produced did not sufficiently demonstrate, at the financial year-end, that the receivable was impaired. In the circumstances of the case, the subsidiary’s losses were not enough to justify the tax deduction of the provision recorded.

TA Rennes (Rennes Administrative Court), 1st October 2026, no. 2305572, Solano Investissements

2. At the outset: the intention to recover

In the Groupe Adeo decision, the chronology weighed heavily: a subsidiary loss-making for three financial years, a proposed voluntary winding-up, then an advance granted and provisioned four days later. The Conseil d’État (France’s highest administrative court) upheld its classification as non-commercial aid: the parent company could be regarded as never having intended to obtain repayment of the advance. Neither the advance nor the provision was therefore deductible.

CE, 30 March 2026, no. 499612, Groupe Adeo

Two separate questions

  • At the outset: is the advance genuine financing intended to be repaid?
  • At year-end: what specific evidence justifies the risk of non-recovery and the amount provisioned?

In practice

The chronology of decisions and the quality of the evidence are decisive in securing the deduction. It is therefore essential to document the prospects of repayment from the moment the financing is granted, and then to update the analysis at each year-end, with dated financial information and well-supported figures.

Related topics

Prior notification of employees: the 2026 reform

Prior notification of employees: the 2026 reform

The obligation to inform employees in advance of a sale of a controlling interest in a company or of its business (fonds de commerce), introduced by the law on the social and solidarity economy, has been reformed by the law on simplifying economic life.Law No....

read more