Management fees and URSSAF: the ruling of 4 June 2026

Engineering and asset management consulting | Accounting expertise

Invoicing a company director’s duties through a holding company or a third-party company is common practice in groups of SMEs and mid-sized companies. In a ruling of 4 June 2026 published in its Bulletin, the French Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) draws a clear line.

Key points

  • A management fees agreement that merely pays for the duties of the president of an SAS is added back to the company’s social security contribution base.
  • The court does not need to check whether the director personally received the amounts invoiced.
  • URSSAF (the French social security collection agency) can issue a reassessment without using the abuse-of-law procedure, and the director no longer needs to be made a party to the proceedings.

Cass. 2e civ., 4 June 2026, no. 23-20.189, FS-B

What the Court of Cassation ruled

An SAS had signed a management agreement with a third-party company represented by the same person. That company invoiced the SAS for general management, sales management and financial management services, provided by making the SAS’s own director available to it.

Following an audit covering 2015 and 2016, URSSAF added the invoiced amounts back to the contribution base. The Metz Court of Appeal upheld the reassessment, and the Court of Cassation dismissed the appeal.

“

Such an agreement amounts to paying for the duties of president.

Reasoning of the Court of Appeal, approved by the Court of Cassation (ruling of 4 June 2026, § 22)

French Social Security Code (CSS), art. L. 311-3, 23° and L. 242-1

Four takeaways

01

Scope is decisive

If the services invoiced overlap with the management duties performed as a corporate officer, the invoice does not change the nature of the amounts.

02

It does not matter who receives the money

The court does not need to establish whether the director personally had the use of the amounts: the fact that the holding company received them does not prevent them from being added back.

03

No need for abuse of law

This procedure, which offers more protection, requires an intentional element. Without proof of an intention to avoid contributions, an ordinary reassessment is enough.

04

The director is no longer joined

A reversal of case law: the dispute concerns the company’s contribution base, not the director’s affiliation. The director no longer has to be made a party.

CSS, art. L. 243-7-2; previous case law overturned: Cass. 2e civ., 9 March 2017, nos. 16-11.535 and 16-11.536 ; Cass. 2e civ., 10 November 2022, no. 21-11.806

What the ruling does not call into question

Management fees are not ruled out as such. What is penalised is an agreement whose purpose is indistinguishable from the corporate office.

Genuine services, provided by an entity with its own resources and covering a scope distinct from management duties, remain defensible, provided this can be demonstrated.

Reviewing your agreements

In practice, we recommend checking four points:

✓

Scope
Does the agreement describe specific services that are distinct from the role of president (managing and representing the company)?

✓

The provider’s substance
Does the holding company have its own employees, expenses and resources, or even other clients? An entity with no resources and no other client has the most exposed profile.

✓

Documentation
Detailed invoices, deliverables, reports and time tracking help prove that the services were actually provided.

✓

The cost of the risk
If the fees are reclassified, the amounts are subject to contributions under the ordinary rules. It is better to estimate this scenario, and compare it with paying the corporate officer directly, before an audit rather than after.

How does this ruling affect your situation?

Get in touch with our teams

Related topics